Climate Change

US leads Bitcoin mining as China ban takes effect

US leads Bitcoin mining as China ban takes effect

China's share of global Bitcoin mining has fallen to effectively zero, research by the Cambridge Bitcoin Electricity Consumption Index (CBECI) suggests.

In June China told banks to stop facilitating transactions, and issued bans on mining.

At its peak in Sept 2019 China accounted for over three quarters of all Bitcoin mining.

China's crackdown initially led to a 38% fall in mining globally CBECI said.

However this was partially offset by a 20% "bounceback" over July and August, "suggesting that some Chinese mining equipment has been successfully redeployed overseas", researchers said.

China has since declared all Bitcoin transactions illegal - though that occurred after the period covered by they Cambridge research.

Miners earn money by creating new Bitcoins, but the computing power needed to do it consumes large amounts of energy.

They audit Bitcoin transactions in exchange for an opportunity to acquire the digital currency.

Global mining requires enormous computing power, which in turn uses huge amounts of electricity, and consequently contributes significantly to global emissions.

The CBECI, which is produced by the Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance, tracks the geographic distribution of computing power used for mining Bitcoin - receiving data from a number of commercial Bitcoin mining pools.

The latest data, which covers the four months to the end of August, suggests that most Bitcoin mining (35.4%) is now US based, with Kazakhstan (18.1%) second and Russia (11%) third.

2px presentational grey line
Analysis box by Joe Tidy, Cyber reporter

You have to almost feel sorry for cryptocurrency miners.

Changing attitudes around the world to crypto are pushing and pulling these businesses in different directions.

The decline of China as a crypto mining powerhouse has been unexpected and rapid.

The government has clearly decided it is dead against crypto in general due to its anonymous and decentralised nature plus the environmental costs that come with mining.

On the flipside Kazakhstan has welcomed these homeless companies with open arms and is seriously cashing in.

Kazakhstan has more than doubled its contribution to crypto mining since April.

But even here there are signs of strain.

Industry insiders tell me that the rapid growth is already putting pressure on electricity levels in some cities and regulation and legislation are likely to be on the way to make the country's crypto boom more sustainable.

2px presentational grey line

China's action in June and the resulting fall in mining will, the researchers say, have been reflected in a decline in Bitcoin's energy consumption - but as mining recovers that fall will reverse.

Currently Bitcoin consumes 0.45% of global electricity production, the Cambridge group estimates.

The researchers do not yet know how the change in the geographic distribution will alter the mix of energy sources used to mine Bitcoin - whether fossil fuel or renewables.

That, they say, will be the subject of future analysis.

Renewable mining

Earlier research by CBECI revealed an annual migration of miners in China - moving between provinces with cheap electricity from fossil fuel to regions where hydro-electric power was abundant in the rainy season.

With the ban miners must look for cheap electricity elsewhere.

Significant amounts of mining in the US is based in areas such as Washington State where low-cost electricity from hydropower is available.

But as the BBC has reported, some Chinese miners have also migrated to the cheap electricity afforded by Texas' deregulated electricity grid.

And Kazakhstan's growth as a mining hub will come at an environmental cost.

According to the US Department of Commerce, 87% of Kazakhstan's electricity "is generated from fossil fuels" with coal accounting for more than 70% of generation.

E-waste rules

Alex de Vries, who runs the Digiconomist blog, told the BBC he thought the changes in where Bitcoin is mined was "bad news for CO2 emissions overall".

But his calculations are based on figures showing how much pollution each kilowatt hour of electricity produces on average in a country, which is a significant simplification.

However, Bitcoin's environmental impact is not limited to greenhouse gas emissions.

A recent study, of which Alex de Vries was a co-author, suggested Bitcoin mining produced thousands of tonnes of electronic waste because the computers used become rapidly obsolete.

Mr De Vries thinks the shifting geography of mining may not alter that much, but notes that "Kazakhstan has no national legislation on e-waste, so the handling of it is even worse than in many other countries".

Trending News

New Year snow flurries fall across England

New Year snow flurries fall across...

Many parts of England have seen snow flurries accompany the arrival of New Year. Areas which welcomed in 2021 with several centimetres...

Covid in Scotland The people who have lost their lives to Covid 19

Covid in Scotland The people who have...

As Scotland's coronavirus death toll passes 6,000 and continues to rise, we are sharing the stories of some of those who have...

Week in pictures 5 11 December 2020

Week in pictures 5 11 December 2020...

A selection of powerful news photographs taken around the world this week. image copyrightJacob King / Reutersimage captionMargaret...

Huddersfield phone mast fire put residents at risk

Huddersfield phone mast fire put residents...

A phone mast fire led to dozens of people being evacuated from their homes in Huddersfield in the early hours.It is not yet known what...

Coronavirus Who is still flying

Coronavirus Who is still flying...

media captionInside the almost deserted Heathrow airportLondon's Heathrow airport normally has about 600 flights landing on an...

When is tax dodging illegal

When is tax dodging illegal...

There are a lot of rash statements being made about whether or not the K2 tax avoidance scheme used by Jimmy Carr was "legal".The...

Our Latest Blog

Click to read Biden election Mike Pence welcomes senators bid to derail result

Biden election Mike Pence welcomes senators bid to derail result

US Vice-President Mike Pence has welcomed an effort by a group of senators to refuse to certify Joe Biden's presidential election...

Click to read Inauguration 2021 What happens on the day Biden is sworn in

Inauguration 2021 What happens on the day Biden is sworn in

Joe Biden is US president-elect. But the Democrat won't officially make his move to the White House until inauguration day - a...

Click to read Nancy Pelosi and Mitch McConnell s homes vandalised

Nancy Pelosi and Mitch McConnell s homes vandalised

Vandals in the US have attacked the homes of the leaders of the two houses of Congress on the eve of a new session and the swearing-in...

Click to read Veteran US broadcaster Larry King in hospital with Covid

Veteran US broadcaster Larry King in hospital with Covid

Veteran broadcaster Larry King, 87, has tested positive for coronavirus and is being treated at a hospital in Los Angeles, according...

Click to read Policeman buys family food instead of arresting them for shoplifting

Policeman buys family food instead of arresting them for shoplifting

A US police officer who was called out to arrest a family suspected of shoplifting instead bought them some food so they could have...

Click to read Suspected Islamists kill dozens in attacks on two Niger villages

Suspected Islamists kill dozens in attacks on two Niger villages

Suspected Islamist militants have attacked two villages in Niger, with reports of dozens of civilians killed. Around 49 died and 17...